Search:

There's a first time for everything
Becoming a mother

A blog about Parenting and Family Life and Personal Journals.
About jbaldwin


Real Name:
Jennifer Baldwin
Member Since:
May 06, 2008
Last Signed In:
November 14, 2008
Profile Views:
463
Blog Views:
1074
View Profile
Send a Message
Send To A Friend
Sign Guestbook
Add as a Friend

Previous Posts
Derek Oliver Burger has arrived!
Baby could be here in a week or two!
Something cute I've noticed
One month to go (give or take)
7 week countdown
On a scale of 1 to 192 ...
Crib vs. Bassinet vs. "play yard"
Only two months to go - Ah!
Oh, THOSE ligaments!
Pass the s'mores ... and some ore!
Archives
May 08
June 08
July 08
August 08
September 08
October 08
November 08
December 08
January 09
Subscribe!
RSS 2.0 feed RSS 2.0
Add to My Yahoo
Add to My Google
Add to Bloglines
Add to My AOL
jbaldwin - > There's a first time for everything -> Crib vs. Bassinet vs. "play yard"
Crib vs. Bassinet vs. "play yard"

As we research baby sleeping arrangements, we are having a hard time deciding what to do. Maybe some of you parents out there have advice.

Of course, we would like a crib for the baby's room. But for the first couple of months, we'd like the baby to sleep in the bedroom with us. So what do we put in the bedroom? Cradles seem unstable, bassinets are way cheesy and frilly, and "play yards" don't seem very durable. But we like the idea of a portable sleeper of some kind that we can have in the bedroom, and take with us when traveling.

We are against co-sleepers (which attach to the bed) because our research has found this is unsafe for the baby, who can fall between the sleeper and the bed and suffocate. For the same reason, some of the "play yards" with the attachable bassinet don't seem safe either.

I'm attaching some photos of products under consideration. But there seem to be pros and cons with them all. Help!

Posted in the Infants interest group.
Topics: motherhood, parenting, maternity
posted by jbaldwin on Monday, September 15, 2008 at 12:56 PM
Report a Violation
Viewed 122 times
8 comments from 7 users

1

posted by LisaW on Sep 15, 2008 at 04:40 PM

We got a Graco Pack N' Play that has a bassinet and a changing table on top, similar to this one. It seems stable to me. I put it together a couple weeks ago. So that's what we're going to use. If she ever decides to show up!

 

posted by jbaldwin on Sep 15, 2008 at 04:47 PM

You haven't popped yet, girl?? When is/was your due date?


posted by LSUDDUTH on Sep 16, 2008 at 08:27 AM

My first one I put right into the crib. I am SOOOOOO glad I did. Night time was never a fight as he got older, he didnt want to sleep with me and he gained a sense of belonging ang grew comfortable to him room. I have never had a problem getting him to go to bed.

posted by TwinZebra on Sep 16, 2008 at 08:45 AM

I put my crib in my bedroom and my daughter slept there for about the first year. Once she got where she could walk (and more importantly, escape from the crib) I put it in the nursery. I had a very small house so there was no need for baby monitors. I could hear my daughter cry in the nursery very easily.

The first couple nights my daughter got out of bed and cried at my locked bedroom door, demanding entry. But I stood fast, and eventually she figured out that she was simply going to HAVE to learn to sleep in her own room.  Same thing happened when my son reached that age.

The one exception was thunder storms. We are all Midwesterners, originally, and the rule of my childhood, which I passed on to my kids, was you could always sleep with Mommy in a scary thunder storm. This made for much comical negotiation at times. A big truck would roll by the busy street behind our back yard and my daughter would insist it was thunder and ask to crawl in bed with me. I'd open the curtains and show her it wasn't raining, and she would reluctantly return to her room.

When we moved to California, and I told the kids there were almost never thunder storms here, my son was relieved but my daughter was deeply disappointed because it meant she couldn't sleep with me anymore.

posted by srfbluemama on Sep 16, 2008 at 11:36 AM

We used a cradle, and just kept it in the locked position. By the time they started moving around a lot at night (3-4 months), they were sleeping longer at night and we transitioned to a crib in their own room.


posted by JulieJordanScott on Sep 17, 2008 at 11:48 AM

I used a bassinette with my son and really liked it. It wasn't too frilly and the size was perfect. He learned how to calm himself early on by kicking his legs against the sides and when I transitioned him to a crib at about 4 months, I just made sure to put him against on the the bumpers on the side... worked like a charm.

I also enjoyed turning on my side and watching his little legs move while he didn't realize I was watching him. :-) One of my favorite tiny baby quiet memories. He was my best sleeper, too. Could be the magical basinette! LOL.

posted by Mom2CandC on Sep 17, 2008 at 02:12 PM

Well, the crib you are considering is just about like the crib we had, which also made into a toddler bed and is now a full size big-boy bed.  I loved it then and really like the versatility now!  When #1 son was born, we also had a bassinet (in the locked position) in our bedroom.  BIG MISTAKE!  From day one our firstborn would fight sleep unless he was being rocked or in bed with us...would never sleep in his crib.  So, with #2 on the way, we vowed not to make the same mistake again!  We brought #2 son home from the hospital and he went straight to sleep in the crib.  To this day, our #2 son will fall asleep on his own, and has never fought falling asleep like #1 son.

Another lesson learned with both sons, don't be afraid to make noise while they are sleeping.  While we kept the house church quiet when it was nap time with #1, at the time of #2 son's arrival, #1 son was definitely the noise maker extraordinaire!  So, #1 son wakes up with the slightest noise, at least until he reached 6 years old....and #2 son can sleep through anything - and I mean ANYTHING!

BTW, if you plan on traveling, doing yard work outside, or enjoy camping with your little one...the pack and plays by Graco are nice, not too expensive, and are lightweight and easy to cart around.  I would recommend the crib and the pack and play with the works.   

   

posted by LisaW on Sep 18, 2008 at 08:19 PM

Nope, still haven't popped. I'm 5 days overdue. Ugh!

1

  (You need to be signed in to leave a comment)