Search:

Groups > Parenting and Family Life > Religion and Beliefs

From: This site All local sites

Showing:

Religion and Beliefs Forum
Discussion Topic: Tension over Santa   Posted By

 We are still almost three months out from Chanukah/Christmas season but I'm dreading it so it's on my mind as early as the fall.

My parents were interfaith. My father, who is deceased, was Jewish. My mother, who is still living, is not. My sister and mother celebrate Christmas.

I am a Jew.  I have always felt perfectly comfortable celebrating Christmas at my sister's house in Los Angeles. I even look forward to the food and decorating the tree. It's a wonderful family bonding time. My mother and sister reciprocate by spending Chanukah with me at my house in Bakersfield.

This arrangement worked fine until my sister and I had kids.

My sister has two girls, ages 5 and 14. The younger one still believes in Santa Claus.

I have a daughter, 6, and son, 3. I am not raising them with the Santa Claus myth. I have told them that Santa was a saint who lived a long time ago, and he was beloved so when he died, Christian parents didn't tell their children he was gone to Heaven lest they be sad. Instead, they took over bringing the presents and told the children Santa was doing it. We mustn't ever tell a Christian child that Santa is dead, because that would break their heart and we don't want to hurt anyone.

I had hoped that would work and for a few years it did, but the year before last my daughter blurted out that there is no such thing as Santa Claus. My sister swooped in and did damage control and as far as I know my little niece still believes, but ever since then Christmas has been very tense.

Usually I spend the night Christmas week to help my sister with cooking and shopping and things. That also spares me a lot of driving because I live two hours away, so it's not easy to go back and forth, especially with today's gas prices. Last year, for the first time, my sister asked me to just come over Christmas afternoon and leave later that day so that her daughters can open their Santa presents free of my children's commentary.

This year I'm sure she'll make the same request. I'm trying to decide if I should go at all. Maybe I should just skip it. I don't want to be anti-social, but I'm going to be so wildly paranoid that my children will say something I don't think I will enjoy myself. The year of the Santa incident my sister was FURIOUS at my daughter for almost ruining the magic. My sister almost stopped speaking to me over it. Plus it's a long drive to only stay there a few hours.

What do you think I should do?

Wednesday, August 20, 2008 at 9:22 am

TwinZebra
1 reply so far <reverse sort order>
suttonwendt
Wednesday, August 20, 2008 at 8:48 pm

 I would say that if you really enjoy being around family during the holiday season, that you should talk to your sister and let her know how you feel, and how much time you would like to spend with her over the holiday. 

I know the kids are young and it may be hard to explain that not all people have the same beliefs, but maybe it might need to be a learning experience for your sister's kids to learn a little about the Jewish religion.  

You may be able to ask the older daughter to help out with watching what the children talk about so that it is not so much pressure on you.

I hope that all goes well and that it doesn't become too stressful of a situation for your family.

Interest Groups Public Beta

Want your blog to show up on the this page?
Choose a category when you add your next post and it will appear on that Interest Group Page.

Start a Discussion
Join this Interest Group and you can talk about it, with other like-minded people!

Questions?
Click here for the Interest Group Beta FAQ